JA Control Panle

Soap opera community photos scoops news buzz and celebrities

  • increase font size
  • Default font size
  • decrease font size
Facebook Twitter YouTube RSS
Home Features Exclusives Come Clean ~ Doom, Gloom, Destruction and Death

Come Clean ~ Doom, Gloom, Destruction and Death

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 0
Soaps, ya gotta lighten up!


Bruce Weitz (Zacchara, General Hospital)I know soap writers can always pump up (albeit temporarily) ratings and revive interest with a drama or murder mystery plot. But lately it seems death, destruction and doom are the predominate themes. Grant it, these storylines make for some captivating movie-lite photo shots, but it ends up being style over substance. Is this all the writers have in their book of tricks? I expect more. I am a big murder mystery fan, but all this death, destruction and gloom just gives me a heavy heart. Hello folks – weren’t soaps supposed to be “love in the afternoon?”

The soap opera headlines shout “Out of the Ashes,” “Murder at the Black & White Ball,” “The Rape of Brooke Logan,” or “The Wedding Whodunit – Shoot Out at the Alter.” The networks work very hard to promote death and murder. Yet, by the time the trial for the murder occurs, usually no one cares or the trial is so tainted that viewers know no one will be brought to justice.  The conclusion to most dramatic storylines never lives up to the promotional hype. The soap creative teams tend to ignore the fact that they are not a prime time drama series!

I think the writers are being lazy when the primary storylines turn into a rotating funeral or murder trial. The death of Jennifer Munson on ATWT really got my dandruff up. The actress was leaving the soap and her character was a member of one of the core families.  Instead of putting her into the typical soap coma or having her mysteriously disappear from the hospital while waiting for a recast, the lazy writers just killed her off!  It is a sign of the times that a death is just so easy and unimaginative for them to do.

Between General Hospital and Days of our Lives, they have racked up as many dead bodies as Jack Bauer on ‘24’!

I think the posters on many of the soap boards have some great idea’s to spice up the storylines.  Along with the In-turn or I Want to be a Soap Star contest, how about a Give us a Storyline contest?  To me, it is obvious the writing teams need a good storyline. Most viewers are not trying to become soap writers, but we could give them some good idea’s to work with. What do you think?  

I love the soap staples of drama, mystery, love, duplicity and trickery. But does all of this have to be done under a cloud of darkness and doom?  Drama doesn’t always have to be murder, death or some horrible event.  I liked the Internet Blogger story plot on one show. A mysterious person was spilling the secrets of the town residents via a web blog. It was a nice twist to an old plot device -- changing the technology of the crime from a scathing unauthorized book to the internet. And who doesn’t love mayhem at a masquerade ball? The costumes and scenery are usually fantastic!  Here are a few of my ideas: Have all the characters on the way to the Daytime Emmy’s and someone is abducted on the way to the event? Or have one of those not-for-profit fundraising events whereby a person gets “arrested” and friends and family bail them out based on the donations collected. But my twist is that no gets that memo so no one raises any funds and the person really gets locked in jail –of course during some critical time that their presence is needed elsewhere.  My ideas may be corny, but my point is that you can have drama and mystery without it being so depressing.  

One only needs to turn on the news to get a daily dose of shootings, murder and death and destruction.  I want my soaps to be a little more light-hearted. Give me some love, intrigue and business shenanigans. It has been said that movie producers tend to create more comedies and ‘feel good’ movies in bad times because people want to escape! But our soap scribes seem to be doing the complete opposite. 

What say you?  Comment below or on the Come Clean Hot Topics Message Board.




Comments (5)add comment

Redrdghood40 said:

I just say thank God they don't need FEMA to get through it! LOL
November 23, 2007
Votes: +0

Nichols25 said:

Yea - whatever happened to love in the afternoon - if I wanted life and death I would watch CNN.
November 23, 2007
Votes: +0

RR73 said:

As usual this writer is right on the mark. A very good and insightful. article. She expresses most viewers sentiments very accurately. I look forward to reading her articles.

I totally dislike reality shows and contests on a Soap Channel but Marla Jones is right, it is time for one featuring a soap writing contest. These need not be full scripts but, an indepth outline. Perhaps the ending could be withheld, so if chosen and used, it would leave the viewers some element of surprise. If enough good entries maybe they could pick more than one. This is a great idea, I hope TPTB read and agree!!!!

She is correct when she says, plots are used over and over. Most pregnancies result in a still birth or miscarriage, or if the baby is born a paternity test must be done as ASAP. Some Children never know their real father. Few weddings make it past “I do”. A lot of sex but little romance. History is totally ignored. After they kill off a beloved character and realize their mistake they return them as ghosts. This is becoming common place, too. Couples do not stay together, as soon as the viewers express an interest in them, the writers break them up.

Currently we tune in to see our favorite actors, not to watch the Story Lines as they are just the same old things rehashed over and over. Two examples are, I wouldn’t watch General Hospital without Jason and Sonny as main characters- but there are other things they can be involved in besides eliminating one Mob Group after an other. Same for OLTL, Todd is the main reason I watch it, his chemistry with his daughter and wife is amazing, but there is a lot he could be doing besides always being arrested and getting divorced and remarried. All three of these characters are interesting and the actors have a lot of chemistry with the entire cast. I hope the soap writing contest is “a go“, and leads to fantastic story lines for all three. Also, for everyone's favorite characters.
November 24, 2007
Votes: +0

Munn2lb said:

I agree with you on how murder, trials, and funerals all see so out-of-this world in how they "work" them out...if only real life was like that! That's almost like the child the never ages or grows up overnight while every one else never ages. Ah the miracles of television. I do wish for a little more ooh,la,la amongst the cast.

Your article is just right.
November 24, 2007
Votes: +0

Chef AC said:

Chef AC
I agree with this article..I could do with less death and more lovin' and steamy storylines.....Besides - we all know just because someone dies - they usually dont stay dead! smilies/grin.gif
November 29, 2007
Votes: +0

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.



Linda Marshall-Smith (QueenRuler, www.Soapdom.com)
New to

Start here!

Past Blast

Days of our Lives Mary Beth Evans on Soap Star, Soap Acting, and Apple Pie
Moonlighting on "I Wanna be a Soap Star," Evans spills the beans about judging, voting people off, and gets us ready for the live season finale, airing October 16th on SOAPnet.

Check It Out

Melody Thomas Scott,, Eric Braeden, The Young and the Restless Snail Mail TPTB
Got a beef? Wanna praise? Looking for an acting gig? Reach out to the powers that be.
Celebrity Buzz and Gossip at www.Soapdom.comCelebrity Buzz & Gossip
Get your daily dose.
Soap Opera Baby Names
Name your baby after your favorite soap character. Get the scoop!
The Soapdom News
Join our newsletter list. Enter your details below.
Email *
First Name *
Last Name *
* Required Field

Soapdom on TwitterSoap Tweets
Follow Your Faves





Latest Poll VOTE Now

What soap opera is your must see TV?

Shout Outs

Login to read messages.

Top Members


Members : 62000
Content : 18361
Web Links : 33
Content View Hits : 24216403